Exploring public discourses about emerging technologies through statistical clustering of open-ended survey questions
نویسندگان
چکیده
The primary method by which social scientists describe public opinion about science and technology is to present frequencies from fixed response survey questions and to use multivariate statistical models to predict where different groups stand with regard to perceptions of risk and benefit. Such an approach requires measures of individual preference which can be aligned numerically in an ordinal or, preferably, a continuous manner along an underlying evaluative dimension - generally the standard 5- or 7-point attitude question. The key concern motivating the present paper is that, due to the low salience and "difficult" nature of science for members of the general public, it may not be sensible to require respondents to choose from amongst a small and predefined set of evaluative response categories. Here, we pursue a different methodological approach: the analysis of textual responses to "open-ended" questions, in which respondents are asked to state, in their own words, what they understand by the term "DNA." To this textual data we apply the statistical clustering procedures encoded in the Alceste software package to detect and classify underlying discourse and narrative structures. We then examine the extent to which the classifications, thus derived, can aid our understanding of how the public develop and use "everyday" images of, and talk about, biomedicine to structure their evaluations of emerging technologies.
منابع مشابه
How We Teach How the story unfolds: exploring ways faculty develop open-ended and closed-ended case designs
Nesbitt LM, Cliff WH. How the story unfolds: exploring ways faculty develop open-ended and closed-ended case designs. Adv Physiol Educ 32: 279–285, 2008; doi:10.1152/advan.90158.2008.— Open-ended or closed-ended case study design schemes offer different educational advantages. Anatomy and physiology faculty members who participated in a conference workshop were given an identical case about blo...
متن کاملEstimated drug use based on direct questioning and open-ended questions: responses in the 2006 National Survey on Drug Use and Health.
Substance use surveys may use open-ended items to supplement questions about specific drugs and obtain more exhaustive information on illicit drug use. However these questions are likely to underestimate the prevalence of use of specific drugs. Little is known about the extent of such underestimation or the groups most prone to under-reporting. Using data from the 2006 National Survey on Drug U...
متن کاملمقایسه دو شیوه ارزشیابی پیشرفت تحصیلی توصیفی و سنتی از دید معلمان و مدیران مدارس دوره ابتدایی شهر شوش
The purpose of this paper is to compare two descriptive and classic academic suc-cess valuations from viewpoint of headmasters and teachers of primary schools in Shoosh during 2008-2009 period. The methodology was descriptive survey and statistical population was all teachers and headmasters of primary schools in Shoosh participating in descriptive valuation plan. Using Krejcie and Morgan Table...
متن کاملA Qualitative Investigation Into Conceptual Understanding at Iranian Elementary Schools
This study attempts to root out some of the causes of absence of conceptual understanding in elementary level particularly in math subject and the factors that cause this deficiency. As a body of researchers, we use a quasi-form of methodology qualitatively designed by which we give a pre-test and post-test to our participants (randomly selected teachers and students), through some open-ended q...
متن کاملHow the story unfolds: exploring ways faculty develop open-ended and closed-ended case designs.
Open-ended or closed-ended case study design schemes offer different educational advantages. Anatomy and physiology faculty members who participated in a conference workshop were given an identical case about blood doping and asked to build either an open-ended study or a closed-ended study. The workshop participants created a rich array of case questions. Participant-written learning objective...
متن کامل